go back

Manual Realignment Of A Broken Collarbone

New York rates for HCPCS 23505

Nonsurgical treatment of a broken collarbone in which the broken ends of the bone are manually guided back into proper position. The arm and shoulder are then immobilized, often with a sling or brace, to allow the fracture to heal without an incision.

Rates data updated October 2026.

How much does Manual Realignment Of A Broken Collarbone cost?

$3,429typical total for the visit

Insurers have agreed to pay about $3,429 for this procedure. That total is two separate charges: $339 to the doctor who performs it, and $3,090 to the hospital or surgery center where it takes place. Done somewhere without a facility charge, you pay only the first.

These are rates insurers have negotiated with providers, not the amount a patient is billed. What you owe depends on your plan's deductible and coinsurance. Based on rates published by 9 insurance carriers under federal price transparency rules.

What's inside this number

Part of the billTypicalRange
Physician feeThe doctor who performs it$339$302 to $380
Facility feeThe hospital or surgery center$3,090$1,380 to $4,786

How much rates vary

Facilitymedian $3,090 · 10th to 90th $692 to $7,244Professionalmedian $339 · 10th to 90th $275 to $617
$200$500$1K$2K$5K$10Kfacility $3,090professional $339

Distribution of negotiated rates across all payers (price axis is log-scale). Need provider-level prices or 24+ months of history? Contact us.

Rates by insurance carrier

Insurance Carrier
Aetna
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$1,348.96
Median
$4,265.80
Typical High
$9,772.37
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$338.84
Median
$363.08
Typical High
$380.19
Anthem BCBS
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$1,288.25
Median
$3,890.45
Typical High
$7,943.28
Anthem BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$275.42
Median
$323.59
Typical High
$478.63
Anthem BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
50 · Both sides
Typical Low
$416.87
Median
$489.78
Typical High
$707.95
CDPHP
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$1,148.15
Median
$1,348.96
Typical High
$4,073.80
CDPHP
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$478.63
Median
$478.63
Typical High
$512.86
Cigna
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$954.99
Median
$1,513.56
Typical High
$3,019.95
Cigna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$331.13
Median
$354.81
Typical High
$812.83
Emblem Health
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$316.23
Median
$426.58
Typical High
$1,348.96
Emblem Health
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$331.13
Median
$489.78
Typical High
$741.31
Excellus BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$213.80
Median
$371.54
Typical High
$489.78
MVP Health Care
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$331.13
Median
$3,235.94
Typical High
$4,365.16
MVP Health Care
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$316.23
Median
$316.23
Typical High
$912.01
United
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$549.54
Median
$1,862.09
Typical High
$4,897.79
United
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$245.47
Median
$371.54
Typical High
$831.76
Univera
Setting
Facility
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$229.09
Median
$331.13
Typical High
$1,258.93
Univera
Setting
Professional
Modifier
None
Typical Low
$251.19
Median
$331.13
Typical High
$489.78
15 more rates with less common billing modifiers

A modifier changes what was billed, for example a reduced or repeated service. Each of these modifiers carries under 10% of the published rates for this code. Modifier combinations, and modifiers with fewer than 30 rates for a carrier, are not listed.

Insurance Carrier
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
52 · Reduced service
Typical Low
$169.82
Median
$181.97
Typical High
$190.55
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
53 · Discontinued
Typical Low
$67.61
Median
$72.44
Typical High
$75.86
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
54 · Surgery only
Typical Low
$257.04
Median
$269.15
Typical High
$281.84
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
55 · Aftercare only
Typical Low
$51.29
Median
$53.70
Typical High
$57.54
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
56 · Pre-op care only
Typical Low
$33.88
Median
$36.31
Typical High
$38.02
Aetna
Setting
Professional
Modifier
78 · Unplanned return to OR
Typical Low
$239.88
Median
$251.19
Typical High
$263.03
Excellus BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
54 · Surgery only
Typical Low
$165.96
Median
$288.40
Typical High
$416.87
Excellus BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
55 · Aftercare only
Typical Low
$44.67
Median
$77.62
Typical High
$109.65
Excellus BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
56 · Pre-op care only
Typical Low
$21.38
Median
$37.15
Typical High
$52.48
Excellus BCBS
Setting
Professional
Modifier
78 · Unplanned return to OR
Typical Low
$147.91
Median
$251.19
Typical High
$363.08
MVP Health Care
Setting
Professional
Modifier
53 · Discontinued
Typical Low
$186.21
Median
$190.55
Typical High
$275.42
Univera
Setting
Professional
Modifier
54 · Surgery only
Typical Low
$165.96
Median
$309.03
Typical High
$389.05
Univera
Setting
Professional
Modifier
55 · Aftercare only
Typical Low
$44.67
Median
$81.28
Typical High
$190.55
Univera
Setting
Professional
Modifier
56 · Pre-op care only
Typical Low
$21.38
Median
$38.90
Typical High
$91.20
Univera
Setting
Professional
Modifier
78 · Unplanned return to OR
Typical Low
$147.91
Median
$269.15
Typical High
$338.84

Where New York sits

The same service costs 5.0 times more in Colorado than in Delaware. Every bar is a state, most expensive first. Touch or drag across it to read any state, then open that state for its carriers and full range.

Physician feeFacility fee

New York· 4th of 51

$3,429

$339 physician + $3,090 facility

CO $4,270DE $861

Median negotiated rate in each state, from every insurer that publishes one. States where no insurer publishes a rate for this service are not shown.